Chronic Self-Doubt and Low Self-Trust: When You Keep Questioning Yourself Despite “Knowing Better”

If you struggle with self-doubt, it may not look like insecurity in the traditional sense. You’re thoughtful. You reflect. You consider all angles. You take responsibility seriously.

And yet:

  • You second-guess decisions

  • You seek reassurance even when you’re capable

  • You struggle to trust your instincts

  • You fear getting it wrong, socially, professionally, emotionally

This isn’t a lack of confidence. It’s often a nervous system pattern.

How Self-Doubt Develops

Chronic self-doubt often forms in environments where:

Approval felt conditional

  • Emotional needs were minimized

  • You learned to monitor others closely

  • Mistakes carried emotional consequences

Over time, your system learned that safety came from checking, anticipating, and correcting yourself.

Why Insight Doesn’t Resolve It

Many women understand why they doubt themselves, yet still feel stuck in it.

That’s because self-trust isn’t built through logic alone. It’s built through repeated nervous system experiences of safety, agency, and internal permission.

EMDR therapy helps process the experiences that taught your system it wasn’t safe to rely on yourself, allowing trust to rebuild organically, not forcefully.

What Healing Looks Like

As self-trust strengthens, clients often notice:

  • Less mental spiraling

  • More ease in decision-making

  • Increased tolerance for uncertainty

  • A quieter inner critic

Self-trust doesn’t mean never doubting, it means not abandoning yourself when doubt arises.

If anything you read resonates or interests you, I encourage you to connect for a free, no pressure, 15 minute phone consultation.

By Lisa Slone, LCSW-R | EMDR Therapist

Next
Next

Emotionally High-Functioning, Internally Overwhelmed: Why “Doing Well” Doesn’t Always Mean Feeling Well